Sunday, July 5, 2009

Bryce Petty, ole buddy ole pal


As expected, Team USA was crowned the inaugural IFAF Junior World Champion, defeating Canada 41-3 in the Gold Medal Game. To earn their spot in the championship game, Team USA defeated France by 78 and Mexico by 55 -- both were shutouts.

Tennessee fans may find it interesting that the quarterback of the junior world champs was former Vol 2009 commit (and current Baylor signee) Bryce Petty. You might recall, Petty committed to Phillip Fulmer before his firing, but when Lane Kiffin took the reigns in Knoxville, he cut ties with the Midlothian, Texas quarterback citing that Petty did not fit the system that he planned to implement.

Granted, it doesn't sound like the other teams were very competive, but Petty had a very nice line. He was 14-14 for 190 yards and 3 touchdowns -- a pretty good day regardless of the competition.

Petty's comments after the game:

"It has been an amazing experience," said Petty, whose three-game totals in the tournament were 25-for-30, 382 yards, six touchdowns and no interceptions. "I can't even put into words what this has been like. I am extremely blessed."I have had good practices, but nothing like today. About 12 of those were five-yard hitches and they turned it up field. We have athletes on this team."

The best of luck to this young man in the future.

Sunday Quarterback Rumor Mill - Scroggins and Sims


So, it was a quiet Independence Day for the most part. Not a whole lot of news to blog about as most took some time off to enjoy the holiday. I hope both of you Vol Critic readers had a great weekend.

While there isn't any real news to report, there were a couple of interesting rumors floating around recruiting circles on Sunday.

First off, and I have no idea where this one originated, reports surfaced that Virgina four star quarterback Phillip Sims might decommit from Alabama and commit to Tennessee. I don't believe there was much to it, and to confuse the matter further, the rumor might have actually been about Blake Sims, who is also committed to Alabama. Blake attended Tennessee's camp over the summer and there was some thought at that time that he might be considering the Vols. Either way, there doesn't appear to be much substance here.

The other rumor generating some buzz on the internet is in reference to California signal caller Jesse Scroggins. Signing a top-rated quarterback is a must in this class for Kiffin and Scroggins appears to be on top of Tennessee's recruiting board. That's why these reports that he will commit USC next week are worrisome. This particular rumor has Scroggins following his childhood friend Dion Bailey to Southern Cal. There are many that have followed his recruitment closely that believe he is a USC lean, but in this case, I don't think this was anything more than a hunch by someone trying to up their 'street cred'.

Scroggins has said that he would not announce his college choice until July 25th. But recently, there has been some talk that it could be moved up to as soon as next week. Most believe, if that were to happen, it could be a result of the USC staff pressuring him to go ahead and pull the trigger.

Saturday, July 4, 2009

Michael Palardy -- He's only a kicker.



Maybe it's just me, but when I think of kickers, the first thing that comes to my mind is the interview with Peyton Manning where he refers to the Colts kicker, Mike Vanderjagt, getting liquored up and running his mouth. I don't even recall what said, but I remember the incident. Regardless, it isn't a positive portrayal and I'm certain kickers don't prefer to be thought of that way.

Lets face it, kickers are odd characters. They are of a different breed -- at least that's the stereotype. For example, they don't like for teammates to talk to them before an important kick. I might even categorize them as loners. And I don't really consider them (or punters for that matter) to be athletes. At least not to the extent that I would other position players on the squad.

So it's easy to understand why fans typically don't get excited about a verbal commitment from a kicker. That is, of course, unless it's from one of the top kickers in the nation. And Michael Palardy from Ft. Lauderdale, Florida is just that, one of the best in the country. An astounding 98% of his kickoffs resulted in touchbacks and he made 76 of his 78 extra point attempts. Not too shabby. In fact, Flavarsity.com referred to him as one of the best clutch kickers in the state of Florida.

Still not convinced that getting a commit from a top-ranked kicker is a big deal? Consider this: scholarships are valuable, and unlike most other positions, coaches aren't going to sign multiple kickers in a recruiting class, meaning there is no room for error. It's critical to bring in a guy who can absolutely get the job done. For Lane Kiffin and Tenneasee, Michael Palardy appears to be just that guy.

Palarady's commit has generated a lot of buzz this week, not just in Tennessee, but in recruiting circles nationwide. I've read multiple articles on his decision from throughout the southeast, including the enemy territories of Baton Rouge and Florida. On a Tennessee message board I frequent, a rival Alabama fan posted a congratulatory thread to Vol fans on the commitment. That's right, a Bama fan envious of a commitment from a kicker.

So yeah, even though this commit is from a kicker, it is great news for Vol fans.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Lane Kiffin and the case of Evan Berry

So, Tennessee headlines the national news again this week. Ho hum.

Evan Berry, 13-year-old eighth grader to be, brother of current Tennessee star Eric Berry and son of former Vol James Berry, has committed to play his college football at Tennessee.

It's the first commitment (and likely to be the only one for quite some time) of the 2013 class for Lane Kiffin and company.

So what's the big deal and why does this story continue to cross my news reader? Admittedly, 2013 is a long time from now and teams don't typically have players claiming to be committed to their school this far in advance. In fact, the NCAA doesn't allow coaches to even contact players of middle school age. But we all realize (well, most of us do) that the Tennessee staff is not out actively pursuing talent for the 2013 class. Berry is a Tennessee legacy - twice over - who believes at this point, he likely wants to follow in the footsteps of his dad and his brother and become a Volunteer some day. Sound reasonable?

Even though this particular absurdly early commit passes the "reasonability test", the media is still going to spin the fact that Berry is only 13.

Chris Low of ESPN.com labels this a 'recruiting stunt' by Kiffin, and while some may believe Kiffin is a mastermind of manipulating the media, I hardly believe that's the case here. More than likely, what we have is an overzealous reporter digging for headlines at a middle school track event.

Low tells us that this commit is insignificant and we should check back in five years - and I agree. Yet the story has headlined not one, but two of his blogs so far this week. Hmmm.

For now, Low says, we should just allow Evan Berry to be a kid. My question is, who is the "we" that he is referring to? I certainly hope that is directed toward himself and the other media who are trying to spin this into a major news headline while mocking Tennessee in the process.

Oh, one more thing Chris. If this was in fact a publicity stunt by Kiffin, he thanks you for your participation -- SUCKER!

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Knoxville Media Turns the Corner


When the Tennessee coaching search was set in motion, just after Phillip Fulmer's dismissal, there weren't many Lane Kiffin supporters to be found among the Knoxville media. Kiffin was too young, too inexperienced, and he had recently been fired from his current job in Oakland. Nevermind his accomplishments or the quality of staff that he could likely assemble, it just wasn't a good fit.

Even weeks later, after Kiffin was hired, things didn't change. I'm sure you remember. It was a questionable hire, they said. A 33 year-old NFL dropout with no college head coaching experience couldn't have possibly been Tennessee's first choice. Something had gone terribly wrong.

Perhaps the media prejudice towards young Kiffin arose from loyalty to coaches that were fired, or maybe it was simply the fear the unknown. Either way, there was undoubtedly a certain familiarity and comfort with the previous staff, which is very understandable considering the length of time that regime was in place.

It's also possible that media members were disappointed and embarrassed that none of their "likely replacements" were hired (Bill Cowher, John Gruden, or Butch Davis). I certainly don't recall any of them campaigning for Lane Kiffin as their candidate of choice, and as a result, they appeared uninformed.

But those days are behind us.

Yesterday was the first day of spring practice under new coach Lane Kiffin, and area media are suddenly gushing with excitement over what they witnessed on the football field. Once considered too young and inexperienced, Lane Kiffin now runs the best first day of practice in the history of football practices. A blueprint should be recorded and enshrined forever so all future generations can experience such greatness. We are being told that it was perfect -- physical, well organized, intense, and yet simplistic and fundamental.

I don't know why we've seen this sudden change, but now that the transformation is complete, I must caution you. Remember these words: physical and fundamental. Those are the adjectives that will be overused all spring and summer. They will be preached by the staff and repeated mindlessly by the media. Come fall, if they aren't careful, fans will be expect to see the most physical and fundamental team in the Southeastern Conference take the field.

Understand, I don't have a problem with the media being positive about practice. I'm certain the new regime, in many ways, is refreshing to everyone. It's even possible that Tuesday may have been an exceptional first day. Without question, football is a physical game and, absolutely, fundamentals are essential. But don't be blinded by the shine of the newness or seduced by the sound of football cliche's just because they originate from the lips of a different staff.

Last season, fans were promised a new offense (Clawfense) that would get the ball in the hands of play-makers in the open field. (What an innovative concept!) It was theme of the off-season. But as we quickly learned, having it said and printed repeatedly doesn't make it so.

Because I've let you in on this little secret, you will no longer be hyptonized by the establishment whenever you hear those words (physical and fundamental). Instead, they will serve as triggers that remind you of reality. And the reality is, this will be a process, a long process, that begins with a 5-7 football team.

I realize Tennessee fans are starving for success. So, before you label me, understand that all I'm asking is for realistic expectations - from both fans and media. It was the first day. At the very least, wait until Friday, when the team is sporting full football gear, before declaring the Vols' impending wrath upon the world of college football.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Tuesday Morning Orange Juice


I decided to come up with a catchy name for posts here that address happenings around the interwebs -- quick hits if you will. Some call them talking points, daily roundup, quick hitters, etc. You get the idea. So, along those same lines, I decided to call ours.... "Morning Orange Juice".

Yes, I realize it's corny but it's the best I could come up with -- and it does include the word orange, which just happens to be Tennessee's primary color (in case you were unaware). Keep in mind, there is a fine line between corny and cleverly genius.

Moving along.

  • I voiced my displeasure of Tennessee basketball fans in Sunday's post-game piece. Expectations were set so high to start this season that many consider 19 wins and a co-SEC East championship to be a disappointment. It's a shame, really, that Bruce Pearl has to build up his teams' accomplishments as he did in yesterday's press conference. Even the University was forced to point out that this year's team has plenty to be proud of.
  • Chris Low sat down with South Carolina's Alshon Jeffrey to talk about the recruiting process and Jeffrey had an interesting comment regarding Lane Kiffin:
  • According to Jeffrey and Wilson, Kiffin told Jeffrey that if he chose the Gamecocks, he would end up pumping gas for the rest of his life like all the other players from that state who had gone to South Carolina.
    Should Kiffin have said something like this to a potential recruit? Probably not. I certainly don't think it helps his cause -- it didn't with Jeffrey. But on the other hand, I'm sure it's not the worst thing ever said on the recruiting trail. Typically most kids just choose not to pass those tidbits along to the media.
  • A poster on VolNation.com (I spend a lot of time there and consider it my "home" board) posted a nice story about bumping into Charles Davis. The former Vol has done very well for himself, but most impressive to me is I've never heard anyone say anything negative about him.
  • Does anyone else find it ironic that talk out of Camp Kiffin this week is, typically, it can take two years to implement a new system and see positive results from it? In Hooker's piece he quotes Monte citing Nick Saban's transition from a 7-6 team his first season to a 12-2 title contender in year two. Can you think of anyone else who claimed a two year time frame was needed when installing a new system? That's right, the much ridiculed Dave Clawson and his Clawfense.
  • Drew Edwards put together a list of big things (his words, not mine) for the Vols as spring practice starts. While I don't completely agree with his list, he hits on a few of them. I'm putting a lot of stock in number five: the players buying in. I fully expect they will, yet I'm very interested to see the on-field discipline, especially of the offense, which has been clearly lacking under non-Cutcliffe coached Tennessee teams.
  • While not totally sports related, I found it very interesting that the four major newspapers in the state of Tennessee (Knoxville News Sentinel, The Tennessean, Memphis Commercial Appeal, and Times Free Press) will begin sharing content. More evidence that the print media business is really struggling.
  • The Georgia Sports Blog, in reference to the Dawgs' ongoing coaching search, put together a list of salaries earned by college basketball coaches around the country. Of those, Billy Gillespie at $2.3 million stood out to me. Hmm.
  • The ACC & SEC Blog projects Southeastern Conference teams in the NCAA Tournament. I agree with their top four (LSU, Tennessee, South Carolina, and Auburn), but I disagree that Kentucky and Mississippi State are 'likely out'. I contend that the league's automatic bid is the only way either will make it. Patrick Patterson will play in the NIT, like it or not.

Monday, March 9, 2009

Scheduling has been Key for Tennessee Basketball


Bruce Pearl has always been an advocate of playing a difficult regular season schedule and this season has been no exception. The Vols strength of schedule has ranked number two or three in the country for most of the year, and for good reason. Looking at their out of conference games, it's easy to see why -- Sienna, Georgetown, Gonzaga (twice), Temple, Marquette, Kansas, and Memphis. Of those games, only Memphis and Gonzaga were played in Knoxville.

The go anywhere and play anyone approach has served Bruce Pearl well during his tenure at Tennessee. The Vols played their way to a No. 2 NCAA Tournament seed twice in Pearl's three trips to the Big Dance. In each case, strength of schedule was essential in obtaining such a high seed.

This year has been no different. Tennessee's RPI, influenced by their strength of schedule, is the key component that currently differentiates the Vols from the log jam of 19+ win SEC schools. Aside from Tennessee and LSU, the other teams are paying the price for poor scheduling and consequently, are bubble teams at best. Those schools are going to need a strong showing in the upcoming conference tournament to punch their ticket to the NCAA tournament.

In his Monday press conference, Coach Pearl acknowledged that scheduling has served him well -- it's something that he believes in strongly and will continue in the future. However, this season it's been somewhat of a negative for his young team because it hasn't allowed them to build any confidence or momentum by putting together 5,6, or 7 wins in a row. Regardless, Pearl insists that his formula for success is working.

The question then, is if strong scheduling is such a benefit, why doesn't every school do it? The answer is simple according to Pearl -- job security. Due to high expectations and the emphasis on winning NOW, typically about half of all coaches are on the hot seat and are therefore reluctant to schedule better teams. It's high reward, but also very high risk. If a coach over schedules and his team doesn't perform, that coach may not be back the following season. That's the reality.

Sunday, March 8, 2009

Hungover in Knoxvlle - Tennessee Falls to Alabama 70-67


Excruciating. That's the word I would use to best describe today's 70-67 loss to Alabama. The three point prayer by Anthony Brock at the buzzer spoiled the Vols chances for 20 regular season wins.

From the beginning, the the body language of both our players and fans was horrible. Everyone in the arena behaved as if they were suffering from a hangover. And the students were apparently still sleeping theirs off. The student section behind the basket was practically empty.

With about ten minutes to go in the first half, Wayne Chism motioned and pleaded to the students to get up and get loud. The response? About five of them stood up and clapped. It's a pretty sad state of affairs when the mascot game of musical chairs and the kiss cam get more of a reaction than the basketball game.

As for the players, it was glaringly obvious they didn't bring the same level of intensity they showed the last two road games. With the exception of a couple stretches in the second half, they played uninspired basketball .

The bottom line is fans didn't create a hostile environment and the Alabama players wanted this game more than the Tennessee players. The Crimson Tide deserved to win.

On the positive side, I give props to the person that came up with the idea to honor Ryan Childress. During warm-ups, the players all wore shirts that stated: "Childress #34 Senior".

The other positive was Wayne Chism. I thought he was the only player that played with any passion and energy. His outside shooting and defense ignited the run that erased a double-digit Alabama lead.

I'll close with this thought: can we please stop talking about Anthony Brock and his "great story" now? I mean, he missed his flight and drove from Arkansas. Good for him. But it's not like he walked... barefoot... uphill the entire way. The media is always looking for an angle.

What other bloggers had to say:

If You Take Me Back I Promise I Will Change -- and This Time I Really Mean It


As it turns out, even though I've only made a few posts here, this blog is like the steady girlfriend that I keep leaving behind and yet she keeps taking me back. Recently, I've spent time chasing other hot blogs around the internet. Some lasted and some didn't. Some were fulfilling for short time and some weren't. Yet here I am, back at The Vol Critic after an absence of nearly a year.

So why didn't I just start a new blog? I could have done that, but it's too much work. I tend to spend enormous amounts of time preparing for new things instead of just doing them. No, what I need is to log more time hammering on the keyboard -- not more time trying to pick out themes and tweak css files. I spend enough time doing that for some of my other interests.

So, here I am, but why? This blog always remains in the back of my mind for some reason. I seem to be drawn to it. Hopefully this time I can make a commitment and not walk out on her. (Is it weird that I keep referring to this blog as "her"?)

Any questions? Now that we have that reintroduction (sort of) out of the way, let's get to it.

There's a lot on the docket right now in the world of Tennessee sports. The football team begins Spring practice on Tuesday and there's going to a ton of material to get through in the next few weeks. It's likely going to be a media circus with Kiffin and company -- new coaches, a new class of players, new offensive and defensive schemes, full media access, and even a practice open to the fans. It's certainly going to be a lot different that any Spring we've had around Tennessee in quite some time. Buckle your seat belts and hold on.

But for now, I want to stick with basketball.

Less than two weeks ago, the Vols basketball team suffered an embarrassing loss to the Kentucky Wildcats in Lexington by 19 points. To make matters worse, that loss was on the heels of a 16-point drubbing at the hands of Ole Miss in Oxford. Fans were questioning the heart, drive, and overall talent of this basketball team. Even our fearless leader, who could do no wrong the past three seasons, was suddenly under attack.

After that Kentucky loss, Pearl called out his players. He said they quit and weren't representative of a "Bruce Pearl coached team". Pearl also called out himself and his coaching staff. With NCAA Tournament hopes dwindling, the Bruce Pearl era had hit its low point and bandwagon fans were jumping ship.

The following game, Tennessee returned home to try and get well against Mississippi State. The Vols won the game, 81-76, but weren't overly impressive in victory. Nevertheless, this team needed wins on their resume, and they got a crucial one against the Bulldogs.

But 17 wins wasn't going to be enough to get this basketball team into the Big Dance. Most analysts believe that with 18 wins, Tennessee would be a bubble team. However, with 19 wins, they would be a lock. The good news: the Vols could hit that mark by winning two of their final regular season games. The bad news: two of the remaining three games were road games against teams that were also battling for their tournament lives -- Florida and South Carolina.

Fast forward to the high point. Tennessee dismantled Florida in Gainesville 79-74, in a game that was not nearly as close as the score, and just days later, with the SEC Eastern Division title on the line, Bruce Pearl and company destroyed South Carolina by 17 in Columbia. With the wins, the Vols locked up a No. 1 Seed in the SEC Tournament.

Currently Tennessee stands with 19 wins and will have a chance to earn number 20 later today against Alabama.

All aboard! Fans are now knocking each other down to climb back on the bandwagon. This time, more fanatical than ever. The talks are now of a conference tournament championship and a possible appearance in the Elite 8. All of this from a team that fans had written off just a couple weeks ago. Makes you understand why fan is short for fanatical, doesn't it?